Competitor Keyword Bidding

When crafting a Google Ads campaign, one tempting strategy that many businesses adopt is bidding on competitors’ brand names. At first glance, it might seem like a great idea — if customers are searching for your competitors, why not try to swoop in and convert them to your product or service? However, using your competitor’s name as a keyword in your Google Ads targeting could potentially raise your Cost Per Acquisition (CPA) without delivering the value you expected. In this blog post, we’ll explore why this tactic could be backfiring on your business and provide insights to help you determine if it's truly worth it.

What Is Competitor Keyword Bidding?

Competitor keyword bidding is the practice of using the name of a competing brand as a keyword in your Google Ads campaigns. The idea is simple: When potential customers search for your competitor, your ad appears as an alternative, giving you a chance to lure them away. But does this tactic really work as well as it sounds?

The Appeal of Competitor Keyword Bidding

At first, the appeal of this tactic is obvious. Competitor bidding allows you to:

• Intercept Potential Customers: If someone is looking for your competitor, it’s likely they are also in the market for your product or service. Your ad might catch their attention at the right time, providing an opportunity for them to consider your offer instead.
• Brand Awareness: Even if a potential customer doesn’t click on your ad, simply appearing alongside a competitor in search results increases your brand exposure. It can be a subtle way to familiarize customers with your brand.
• Potential Sales: If someone is dissatisfied with your competitor, they might be open to trying out your product or service. Your ad could be their first step toward exploring your offerings instead.

The Downside: How Competitor Bidding May Be Driving Up Your CPA

One of the biggest concerns with using a competitor's name as a keyword is its potential to inflate your CPA — the cost to acquire a new customer. Here are a few reasons why this happens:

1. Higher Bidding Costs

Competitor names are often highly competitive keywords. If your competitors are well-established brands with significant name recognition, it’s likely that multiple businesses are vying for the same keywords. This bidding war can cause keyword prices to skyrocket, meaning you’ll pay more each time someone clicks on your ad.

Not only that, but since you're not bidding on your own brand or a more neutral keyword, Google’s ad algorithm may view your relevance as lower compared to competitors bidding on their own name. This can lead to lower Quality Scores and increase your cost per click (CPC), which directly drives up your CPA.

2. Low Conversion Rates

When a user searches for a competitor by name, they are often looking for something specific. They might be trying to find the competitor’s website, customer support, or specific product information. In many cases, users will skip over your ad because it isn’t what they were searching for, leading to low click-through rates (CTR).

Even if someone does click on your ad, they may not be fully receptive to your brand or offering. After all, they were specifically searching for a competitor. This means your conversion rate could end up being much lower than other campaigns, further increasing your CPA.

3. Negative User Perception

Think about it from the customer’s perspective. If they are actively searching for a specific brand, seeing ads for competitors can sometimes feel intrusive or misleading. A user might click on your ad by accident, only to quickly realize that it’s not the brand they were searching for. This frustration can result in a high bounce rate, wasted ad spend, and ultimately, a higher CPA.

Additionally, some users might perceive this tactic as underhanded. If they were loyal to your competitor, using their brand name to capture attention could backfire, leading to negative brand perceptions and hurting your reputation in the long run.

Pros of Using Competitors’ Names as Keywords

Although the strategy has its risks, there are some potential advantages to bidding on competitors’ brand names. Let’s take a closer look at the pros:

1. Brand Awareness

Even if users don’t click on your ad, your brand still appears next to a well-known competitor. This can increase brand visibility, especially for businesses looking to establish themselves as alternatives in the market.

2. Capturing Dissatisfied Customers

Customers searching for your competitor might be doing so because they are unhappy or dissatisfied with their current choice. This provides you with a window of opportunity to present your product or service as the better alternative.

3. Gain Insights Into Competitor Strategies

By monitoring how your competitor responds to your ad placement (for instance, whether they increase their ad spend or alter their messaging), you can gain insights into their marketing strategies and even develop counter-strategies.

Cons of Using Competitors’ Names as Keywords

Now, let’s dive deeper into the potential drawbacks, particularly how they relate to your CPA:

1. High Cost of Acquisition

Bidding on a competitor's name means you're fighting against both the competitor and other companies in your industry who are using the same tactic. As a result, the cost of placing your ad can be prohibitively high, especially when conversion rates don't justify the spend.

2. Low Relevance and Quality Scores

Google’s ad system prioritizes ads based on relevance. Since your ad isn’t directly related to the competitor’s brand, your ad might be considered less relevant by Google’s algorithms. This leads to lower Quality Scores and increases your CPC, making it more expensive to run ads using competitor keywords.

3. Unqualified Traffic

Many users searching for a specific brand are likely loyal customers. Even if they click on your ad, they may not convert, leading to wasted ad spend. This results in low conversion rates and a higher CPA, further diminishing the profitability of the campaign.

4. Potential Legal Issues

Although it's generally legal to bid on competitors’ keywords, there are instances where doing so could land you in hot water legally. Some brands view this tactic as deceptive, and while trademark policies vary, competitor bidding can sometimes spark lawsuits. Even if you don’t face legal action, this tactic can strain relationships within your industry.

When Competitor Keyword Bidding Makes Sense

Competitor keyword bidding isn’t always a bad idea. In certain situations, it can work well, but it requires careful analysis and execution. Here are a few scenarios where it might make sense:

1. Niche Markets

If you operate in a niche market with few direct competitors, bidding on a competitor’s keyword may give you access to a highly targeted audience at a lower cost. In such cases, the competition for the keyword is less intense, and the CPC might not be as inflated.

2. Unique Value Propositions

If your product or service offers a clear, compelling advantage over your competitor, such as a lower price or significantly better features, competitor keyword bidding can provide an opportunity to highlight these advantages at a critical moment in the buying process.

3. Competitor Failures

If a competitor is undergoing public struggles, such as bad press or product failures, customers may actively be searching for alternatives. This is a good time to capture those users who are already looking to jump ship.

Alternatives to Competitor Keyword Bidding

If you’re starting to think that bidding on competitor keywords isn’t worth the expense, there are other ways to effectively target your competitors' customers without breaking the bank. Here are a few alternatives:

1. Focus on Your Own Brand Keywords

Instead of focusing on a competitor’s brand name, shift your attention to your own brand. By optimizing your ads for your own brand-related keywords, you can improve your relevance, Quality Score, and conversion rates, ultimately driving down your CPA.

2. Use Comparative Ads

Instead of bidding on a competitor's name, create comparative ads that highlight your strengths over the competition. You can use general industry keywords and create ads that show why your product or service is superior to the competition.

3. Leverage Remarketing

Remarketing is a powerful tool to re-engage users who have already interacted with your brand but haven’t converted. Instead of targeting competitor keywords, you can focus on re-engaging those who are already familiar with your offering, driving higher conversions and lowering your CPA.

4. Optimize Landing Pages

To ensure that any traffic you receive converts, focus on optimizing your landing pages. Even if you do decide to use competitor keyword bidding, a highly targeted landing page can help reduce bounce rates and increase conversion rates, thus offsetting the higher CPC.

Wrap Up: Is Competitor Keyword Bidding Worth It?

At the end of the day, bidding on your competitors' brand names in Google Ads can be a double-edged sword. While it may offer some opportunities for increased brand awareness and conversions, the potential for inflated CPAs, low conversion rates, and wasted ad spend cannot be ignored.

The key is to carefully evaluate whether this strategy aligns with your marketing goals and budget. It’s also essential to monitor your campaigns closely and measure your return on investment. In many cases, focusing on your own brand and delivering a compelling value proposition may offer a better return on investment and help you lower your CPA.

So to wrap up, while competitor keyword bidding has its place in the marketing playbook, it’s not always the silver bullet that many advertisers hope for. Make sure to weigh the pros and cons, test thoroughly, and be ready to pivot to other strategies if needed. After all, the ultimate goal is to attract the right customers at the right price, not just to outbid your competitors.

‍